Is SS and Z28 the same thing?

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old Feb 24, 2008 | 12:04 PM
  #11  
Sween's Avatar
Newbie
Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 11
From:
Default RE: Is SS and Z28 the same thing?

ORIGINAL: 95slvrZ28


The LS1 SS's have the same HP as a Z28,
actually , they don't. From 98-02 The SS has the same engine as the z28 but it has different exhaust resulting in 15 extra HP and 5 pounds of torque (320hp and 340 pounds of torque). The SS also has a stiffer suspension, a functional Hood Scoop and also a more aggresive rear spoiler. I think in 00 or 01 it got another 5 hp but I don't know the details on that.
 
Old Feb 24, 2008 | 12:31 PM
  #12  
ninetysixyenko's Avatar
4th Gear Member
Joined: May 2007
Posts: 2,103
From:
Default RE: Is SS and Z28 the same thing?

ORIGINAL: Sween

ORIGINAL: 95slvrZ28


The LS1 SS's have the same HP as a Z28,
actually , they don't. From 98-02 The SS has the same engine as the z28 but it has different exhaust resulting in 15 extra HP and 5 pounds of torque (320hp and 340 pounds of torque). The SS also has a stiffer suspension, a functional Hood Scoop and also a more aggresive rear spoiler. I think in 00 or 01 it got another 5 hp but I don't know the details on that.
that's been proven wrong time in and time out.. at msot, it's a total of 5HP at wheels.
 
Old Feb 24, 2008 | 12:54 PM
  #13  
SpecterGT260's Avatar
Ninja Administrator
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 6,172
From: Potato
Default RE: Is SS and Z28 the same thing?

ORIGINAL: Sween

ORIGINAL: 95slvrZ28


The LS1 SS's have the same HP as a Z28,
actually , they don't. From 98-02 The SS has the same engine as the z28 but it has different exhaust resulting in 15 extra HP and 5 pounds of torque (320hp and 340 pounds of torque). The SS also has a stiffer suspension, a functional Hood Scoop and also a more aggresive rear spoiler. I think in 00 or 01 it got another 5 hp but I don't know the details on that.

ouch.... im going start bleeding from the ears here in a bit...


sween, there is a very specific point to this thread. we are all aware of the rated hp numbers. If we were to take said numbers as fact then there would be no point to this thread, or someone would have just come in here andsaid "THE SS IS RATED HIGHER. DONT FALL FO ALL DIS JIBBA JABBAFOO!" [/Mr. T]

however there was a lengthy discussion. this means one thing: the rated hp numbers are not accepted amongst the fbody community. and for good reason. I own a base model 98 Trans am. no ram air, no fancy doodads, and I dyno'd at 331rwhp with a lid, catback, ypipe, and EGR delete. if i were to fall for the stock ratings, then my 305 advertized hp translates to 260rwhp. This means that I picked up 71rwhp from some basic boltons. That cannot be. also taking into account the fact that every ls1 fbody since 98 has dyno'd in the 290-310 range stock, i tend to believe the ratings are false.

I say all that to say this: all ls1 fbodies have 350hp factory, which is the same as the ls1 vettes, and this is because the motors are identical. the vettes have a fancy elbow exhaust which does nothing for power over the lid setup, and they have dual exhaust which, is still dinky, so it just changes the sound with an accompanying 5 hp. whoopty freakin doo.....

this can all be summed up by saying 350+15=320 [&:]

the suspension and spoiler do not affect power in any way. we have already said in this thread it was a cosmetic upgrade

sorry to come down on u so hard, but this is a topic every fbody forum gets hit with on a regular basis. Its irritating.
 
Old Feb 24, 2008 | 01:03 PM
  #14  
SpecterGT260's Avatar
Ninja Administrator
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 6,172
From: Potato
Default RE: Is SS and Z28 the same thing?

I just noticed u have an SS. they are awesome cars, i personally believe that they look way better than the z28. but dont become one of those guys that buys into the hype and is just an ignorant fanboy. I like to use personal stories when i make my points so here goes another one:

I was busy tuning my car for nitrous when I pulled up to a nearly identical ws6. me and my buddy complimented his car, and he asked what I had. I told him intake, exhaust work, suspension work (which is actually significantly better than the ws6 and ss suspension package). he thought for a second and said, well this has the ws6 performance package on it, so that means u should be a pretty good race for me then!"

[sm=bangbang.gif]

the thing u need to remember is just how completely worthless the upgrades are. most of the changes were not between thez and ss, but between years as GM found better and more cost effective ways to make their engine. ALL 01+fbodies have the ls6 intake manifold. in 01 ( i believe) they got slightly better flowing exhaust manifolds, but not much, and both the z, ss, TA, and ws6 got them. the cam in the 98-00 cars is actually more aggressive than the cam in the 01+ cars, this aided in the removal of the EGR from the later models. so there are differences, but for the purpose of this discussion which is z vs ss, there is no appreciable difference
 
Old Feb 24, 2008 | 01:10 PM
  #15  
TheStig's Avatar
3rd Gear Member
Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 879
Default RE: Is SS and Z28 the same thing?

LS1 = 350 bhp

LS1 Z28 = 350 bhp
LS1 SS = 350 bhp
LS1 T/A = 350 bhp
LS1 WS6 = 350 bhp
 
Old Feb 24, 2008 | 01:12 PM
  #16  
ninetysixyenko's Avatar
4th Gear Member
Joined: May 2007
Posts: 2,103
From:
Default RE: Is SS and Z28 the same thing?

ORIGINAL: TheStig

LS1 = 350 bhp

LS1 Z28 = 350 bhp
LS1 SS = 350 bhp
LS1 T/A = 350 bhp
LS1 WS6 = 350 bhp
you're a genious!!!!![sm=jawdrop.gif][sm=jawdrop.gif]
 
Old Feb 24, 2008 | 01:14 PM
  #17  
SpecterGT260's Avatar
Ninja Administrator
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 6,172
From: Potato
Default RE: Is SS and Z28 the same thing?

thank u the stig.


i actually have a GM booklet that goes through the history and developement of the genIII, as well as its applications. They talk about its build, and go through all its specs, talking about the 350hp, and then a little later they list all the vehicles
Camaro z28 305bhp [&:]. it just magically loses 45hp because its in a fish i guess. they make no justification, just "yep, the ls1 is 350, but its 305 in the fbodies".



another thing that people get wrong alot is they start to think that the rated numbers were meant as rwhp numbers. this is also not true. GM INTENTIONALLY underrated the cars, the 305 is meant to be interpreted as bhp, but it is an incorrect number
 
Old Feb 24, 2008 | 01:18 PM
  #18  
ninetysixyenko's Avatar
4th Gear Member
Joined: May 2007
Posts: 2,103
From:
Default RE: Is SS and Z28 the same thing?

ORIGINAL: SpecterGT260

thank u the stig.


i actually have a GM booklet that goes through the history and developement of the genIII, as well as its applications. They talk about its build, and go through all its specs, talking about the 350hp, and then a little later they list all the vehicles
Camaro z28 305bhp [&:]. it just magically loses 45hp because its in a fish i guess. they make no justification, just "yep, the ls1 is 350, but its 305 in the fbodies".



another thing that people get wrong alot is they start to think that the rated numbers were meant as rwhp numbers. this is also not true. GM INTENTIONALLY underrated the cars, the 305 is meant to be interpreted as bhp, but it is an incorrect number
dude. that 45HP went to the radical look of the F-body cars.. duh....
 
Old Feb 24, 2008 | 10:03 PM
  #19  
YoungDriver's Avatar
2nd Gear member
Joined: Oct 2007
Posts: 325
From: Canada
Default RE: Is SS and Z28 the same thing?

Hahah.. soo true. It's the only explanation. Personally I'd try and get the ugliest possible car alive if that's how it worked.
 
Old Feb 25, 2008 | 08:31 PM
  #20  
Sween's Avatar
Newbie
Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 11
From:
Default RE: Is SS and Z28 the same thing?

ORIGINAL: SpecterGT260

ORIGINAL: Sween

ORIGINAL: 95slvrZ28


The LS1 SS's have the same HP as a Z28,
actually , they don't. From 98-02 The SS has the same engine as the z28 but it has different exhaust resulting in 15 extra HP and 5 pounds of torque (320hp and 340 pounds of torque). The SS also has a stiffer suspension, a functional Hood Scoop and also a more aggresive rear spoiler. I think in 00 or 01 it got another 5 hp but I don't know the details on that.

ouch.... im going start bleeding from the ears here in a bit...


sween, there is a very specific point to this thread. we are all aware of the rated hp numbers. If we were to take said numbers as fact then there would be no point to this thread, or someone would have just come in here andsaid "THE SS IS RATED HIGHER. DONT FALL FO ALL DIS JIBBA JABBAFOO!" [/Mr. T]

however there was a lengthy discussion. this means one thing: the rated hp numbers are not accepted amongst the fbody community. and for good reason. I own a base model 98 Trans am. no ram air, no fancy doodads, and I dyno'd at 331rwhp with a lid, catback, ypipe, and EGR delete. if i were to fall for the stock ratings, then my 305 advertized hp translates to 260rwhp. This means that I picked up 71rwhp from some basic boltons. That cannot be. also taking into account the fact that every ls1 fbody since 98 has dyno'd in the 290-310 range stock, i tend to believe the ratings are false.

I say all that to say this: all ls1 fbodies have 350hp factory, which is the same as the ls1 vettes, and this is because the motors are identical. the vettes have a fancy elbow exhaust which does nothing for power over the lid setup, and they have dual exhaust which, is still dinky, so it just changes the sound with an accompanying 5 hp. whoopty freakin doo.....

this can all be summed up by saying 350+15=320 [&:]

the suspension and spoiler do not affect power in any way. we have already said in this thread it was a cosmetic upgrade

sorry to come down on u so hard, but this is a topic every fbody forum gets hit with on a regular basis. Its irritating.
haha wow. a lengthy discussion? theres what one and a half pages? Someone that has 8 posts ask whats the difference if theres any between a z28 and a SS (I'm guessing he/she is a future buyer). So I answered it. Nobody else gave a straight up answer so I did. Am I one of those people that think the SS is the best type of camaro and its better than everything else? No, but I do realize that its not a huge improvement from the Z28, but its still an improvement. Can I say that the HP is more than a Z28. No cause I havn't dynoed a same year z28 and my ss . I would however take a good guess that it does because the exhuast is so much different. Also I did test drive a stock z28 before purchasing the SS and yes the SS did feel different (like it had an iddy bitty more power), and the suspension makes a big difference. Maybe I was just biased to the SS but whatever.

BTW my dad owns a 99 corvette convertable. I can guarentee you that, that has more power in there somewhere. Maybe its because its just lighter but most likely its not.

Finally I will say that I hope that the camaro fanbase is not a group of people that just thinks that there cars are the best and they claim mumbo jumbo hp ratings. The 08 dodge viper dynos 554 RWHP that could easily be rated at 620 but its rated at 600. The ford gt can easily be rated at 600 hp but its not its rated at 550. Heck the new VW GTI gets 198 to the rwhp but its rated a 200 hp. None of the followering brands fanbases however go around saying my car has 620 HP or 600hp or 220 Hp. Manufacturers do this all the time. The z28
 



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:51 PM.