What do you guys think of these two products?

This one is $80 and is an "Official" part.
http://www.heartbeatcity.com/store/p...ck--pr--68-69/

This one is $9
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00...A21MQ1ED7BL8AN

I see what looks like a tab for a screw or something on the $80 part, but wouldn't mind saving $70.

Thoughts? Suggestions?

 

I installed a set of the $80 ones and the tabs were not long enough to go in the factory holes. When trying to make it fit the tabs wound up coming out of the trim anyway. I dont know how the others fit but probably isnt much worse than the good ones.

 

Well, I don't recall any tabs when mine fell off lol! The cheaper ones are $16 when you consider shipping. Eh, unless anyone has an objection sounds like a shot anyway?