What is the original hockey stick stripe made out of? Looking in Classic Industries you can get a stencil or they claim that the originally came as a a sticker until you get to the door. Then it becomes a stencil that is painted on. Which is the real original hocky stick set up?

The real Hockey Sticks were painted on. That's why You got a stencil. You might contact Year One. I think They have a Decal type hockey stick available.